Abortion, Contraceptives, Hardness of Heart

Explaining why Moses permitted divorce, Jesus said it was "because of the hardness of your hearts" (Mark 10:5). Some scholars argue that Moses allowed divorce to protect women (Deuteronomy 24). In other words, if a man kicked his wife out without divorcing her, she would not be able to remarry—leaving her destitute. Simply put, although divorce is condemned as sin in scripture, the Mosaic law provides specific instructions as to how it should be carried out.

I have mixed feelings about abortion reduction strategies—in the same way I would have had mixed feelings about slavery reduction legislation in the 1860s, partial women's suffrage in the 1910s, lynching reduction plans in the 1940s. It feels like halfhearted justice to me.

In spite of the author's obvious bias, this Slate article on a new abortion reduction bill is informative. However, there is a stumbling block in this bill that has tripped up many conservatives: contraception. The bill explicitly requires grantees to "encourage teens to delay sexual activity." But because it also requires grantees to provide "information about the risks and benefits of all contraceptives", it is anathema to conservatives. I think the concern is that teens will have more sex if they have access to contraceptives, and distributing contraceptives is an implied approval of premarital sex.

My question is this: If Moses were alive today in our postmodern secular culture ...

• ... would he approve of the distribution of contraceptives if it were proven that it resulted in fewer abortions ...


• ... would he support laws that limit access to abortion without outlawing it altogether ...


• ... would he approve of some type of non-marital legal status for homosexual couples ...


• ... would he approve of laws to govern the distribution of substances that may be abused and destroy lives and families ...

... because of the hardness of our hearts?

I don't know where I stand on these questions, and there is not much of a parallel between the theocracy of ancient Israel and the democracy of modern America. But it's worth considering how the law of God is intended to address the inevitability of human sin.